Corn Snakes and Other Colubrids

What can be mistaken for a garter snake?

Ribbon snakes, brown snakes and water snakes are often mistaken for garter snakes. Learn how to tell them apart and what to do if you're unsure.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. How to recognise a garter snake
  3. Ribbon snakes
  4. Brown and other small snakes
  5. Water snakes
  6. What about venomous snakes?
  7. The African “garter snakes”
  8. Identification tips and when to ask an expert
  9. Related guides

Short answer

The snakes most often mistaken for garter snakes are their close relatives, ribbon snakes, along with small brown snakes, water snakes and other slim, striped snakes. Which of these you meet depends heavily on where you live, so local knowledge matters.

How to recognise a garter snake

Garter snakes (genus Thamnophis) are slim, usually 18 to 36 inches long, and most have lengthwise stripes, often yellow, cream or tan, on a darker background. Some are checkered or less distinctly striped. They are common near water, gardens and meadows. For a broader profile, see garter snakes as pets.

Ribbon snakes

Ribbon snakes are in the same genus and look very similar, but they are typically slimmer, with a longer tail and bright, clean stripes. They are often found near water. Because they are so close, the two are commonly confused, and a field guide for your area helps.

Brown and other small snakes

Small brown or gray snakes, such as brown snakes, can look like a dull or faded garter snake from a distance, especially if the stripe is faint. They are generally smaller and have a pale or plain belly, and are often found under debris. Check size, stripe pattern and range.

Water snakes

Water snakes are thicker-bodied than garter snakes and often have bands or blotches rather than clean stripes. Young ones can be patterned and may be mistaken for other snakes. Because they live near water like many garters, they are frequent subjects of “what is this snake?” posts. Water snakes can bite hard and produce musk when handled, so leave them alone.

What about venomous snakes?

In most of North America, venomous snakes do not look much like garter snakes. They are typically heavier-bodied and patterned with blotches or bands. Still, never rely on one feature such as head shape or color to decide a snake is harmless, especially if you are outside the US or Canada. If you cannot be certain, keep your distance and treat it as unknown.

The African “garter snakes”

The name is also used for a few African snakes in the genus Elapsoidea, which are venomous and unrelated to Thamnophis. If you are outside North America, check what “garter snake” means locally.

Identification tips and when to ask an expert

  • Note the location, habitat and time of year.
  • Take a clear photo from a safe distance.
  • Note size, stripe color and pattern, belly color and tail length.
  • Ask a local wildlife agency, herpetological society or a reputable identification group.
  • Do not pick up wild snakes to examine them.

If you are choosing a pet rather than identifying a wild snake, consider captive-bred animals. Which pet snakes don’t eat rodents may also be relevant.

The complete guide to corn snakes and other colubrids

Corn Snakes vs Rat Snakes: Are They the Same?
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →